Russian Ice Hockey verse the US Hockey System

Are the Russians Doing a Better Job at Sports Performance Training(specifically hockey)?

I know that USA Ice Hockey’s USDM is pretty good and that they are making strides to improve the quality of our sports performance training and ice hockey system throughout the entire country.  Below is an outline of the Russian Ice Hockey system.  As you will read, it’s pretty obvious how our sports performance system is lacking based the quality of their coaches and time invested in skill verse playing games like we do here in the US.  Lets face it, Evgeni Malkin was the best ice hockey player in the world last year(2011-2012).  He would be required to spend 5 years in “Sports Schools” before being permitted to coach in the Russian Ice Hockey System.  That’s a far cry from any of the sports systems here.  How many football or baseball coaches even played a division one sport?  Regardless if they did, they sure aren’t an expert in coaching that sport to children.

I think he's going to keep playing...
I think he’s going to keep playing…

I like the Russian Ice Hockey System and feel that something like it should me implemented in every sport in the US to provide a better opportunity for our elite youth to excel.  I feel that all of our youth should be screened and placed into sports and professional fields which will yield them the most success.  Lets stop trying to fit a round peg into a square hole.  Sure there are exceptions but most of those exceptions would be highly successful in other avenues in life.  They are winners and winners find a way to win.

For the children that don’t qualify,  the current participatory system should be implemented with some modifications.  This new system would be focused around physical fitness/exercise and learning the skills of the game instead of competitions.  The coaches(dads and moms) would have to through some coaching classes to qualify to be coaches.  Not technical and tactical(XYZ stuff) aspects of the sport but education on physical fitness and athletic techniques   The University system doesn’t teach that here in the US so the physical education teachers and the parents have never be taught these techniques. Gym classes are being cut everyday and youth sport coaches spend as much time with our youth as the parents who typically both work full time.    This “novice” systems would focus on exercise and sportsmandship.  Aside from the spectator aspect of sport,  doesn’t sport mirror life?  Use sport to teach great lesson about life AND teach the youth about an appreciate for physical health and well being.

Sport Performance Training in Pittsburgh

If the system were corrected. there woud’ve be four AAA(most elite) Youth Ice Hockey Clubs like there are in the Pittsburgh market right now. There wouldn’t be several elite volleyball clubs and over ten “cup” soccer organizations.  I guess just about EVERY parent expects their children to be elite.  On the AAA Pens Elite Midget Major Hockey Team(U-18) which is considered by many to be the best hockey team of it’s kind in the Pittsburgh area, maybe 5 of the 20 players on the team legitimately dry land train.   I’m not even qualifying players that as working with a personal trainer or a sports performance coach.  Training 2-3 times a week in the summer and once a month in season is a joke for an athlete striving to become elite.  These athletes aren’t eating 3,000 plus calories a day and working both on and off the ice with professional experts 4-5 days a week like they should be doing.   All twenty of those players expects to play junior hockey and 90% expect to play collegiate hockey.  Funny how it doesn’t work out for all but one of two of them.  Don’t get me wrong, they are good kids and go on to be successful without hockey.  I just wonder how many could’ve had hockey “pay” for school?

My point is create two systems that will promote the development of both the elite athletes and the novice athletes.  No, we don’t already have that.   Realistically, even the elite sport athletes have a one and a million shot of playing a sport professionally.  Lets teach these kids about physical fitness(which is basically non existent in the US) and about the benefits of practice.  Hard work, discipline, and patience goes a long way to creating a better and healthier generation.

Here’s the blog post in it’s entirety.  The link is at the very bottom..

Thanks to Sean Skahan of the Anaheim Ducks for originally posting this.


 USA Hockey Visits Russia(2008)

Posted by   at January 5th, 2013

Final Report By Al Bloomer

In February 2008 Mark Tabrum and I visited St. Petersburg and Moscow, Russia. The purpose of the trip was to learn about the Russian Coaching Education Program and to observe the differences as well as similarities between USA Youth Hockey and Russian Youth Hockey. Barry Smith and Mikhail Manchik, CKA Ice Hockey Club of St. Petersburg, were our hosts. They made all the on-site arrangements for our visit. The Russian people we visited were very generous with their time and conversations were open and candid. This report is an attempt to summarize the trip. The first part will discuss coaching and coaching education. The second part will describe the philosophies and operation of Russian youth hockey, specifically age six thru the age of 18.

There are 168 indoor rinks in Russia. In 2007, the Russian Hockey Federation reported 25,956 male players, 257 female players and 56,754 junior players. The primary governing body for Russian Hockey is at the club level. The Russian club level is similar to our association level. Russia is divided into six regions for hockey; however, there appears to be no equivalent to our affiliates or districts.

We visited four hockey clubs:

CKA – St Petersburg – our host

Khimik – Moscow

Dynamo – Moscow

CSKA – Red Army – Moscow

We also visited The Basza in St. Petersburg. The former Red Army Hockey HQ was built in 1870 and serves as hockey training center, CKA offices, provides training meals, houses medical staff and provides sleeping quarters.

Coaching Program:

The Russian coaching education system is extensive and demanding.

  • All coaches must have a Sports Degree from an accredited university. This degree is a five-year program and is the equivalent of a Master’s degree. In addition to this general sports degree, coaches take an additional 500 hours of classes specific to hockey. Many Russian coaches are former players. All coaches are required to have skating ability. Goaltender coaches receive additional specialized training.
  • There is emphasis on player athleticism – off ice physical training and physiological development are a significant part of the coaching curriculum. Off ice training begins at age eight; weight training is used based on player testing, usually beginning at age 12. Dry land and strength training is a key component in the development of Russian players
  • All youth hockey coaches are paid professionals. This is their full time job. Salaries vary; ranging from $6,000 to $10,000 per year. There are additional benefits that may include housing, insurance and meals. The coaches can make additional money conducting summer camps. Volunteer coaches are very rare; if they participate, it is on a very supervised and limited basis.
  • The top/best coaches teach at the entry levels (6, 7 & 8 year olds).
  • In some clubs a coach will move vertically through the system with the same birth year. In other clubs the coaches will stay at the same birth year level for up to 10 years.
  • Clubs have three coaches per team (10 and under); two coaches per team for 11-18 year olds. Clubs have at least one goaltender specialist that works with all goaltenders.
  • Clubs have a Hockey Director in charge of the entire program. Clubs also have Coaching Program Directors that establish a detailed daily, as well as yearly, curriculum of development. This curriculum (lesson plan) is followed by all coaches at all levels. There may be coaching councils that offer ideas and suggestions, but ultimately the Coaching Program Director sets the curriculum. While some clubs prepare the detailed lesson plan, others give the coaches the scheduled points to emphasize and allow them to prepare the detailed lesson plan.
  • The coaches are strict disciplinarians. If a player is misbehaving he/she will be told to leave the ice. In one instance we saw a coach firmly “whack” non-attentive players with his stick. Players can be dismissed by the Program Director for discipline issues and/or behavior. There is no hearing and no appeal. We were told that although Directors have the ability to dismiss, it does not happen very often. The coach demands and receives respect on and off the ice. Russian coaches have almost a dictatorial style.
  • Coaches within the club work together. The program is designed for vertical development – moving players to the next level within the club. Standardized curriculum/philosophy allows for smooth transition and players are prepared for the next level. The primary objective is to prepare players for the parent professional club team.
  • Players practice on ice a minimum of five times per week. Each practice lasts from 90 to 120 minutes. In addition, players from age 8-12 will have three off ice training sessions per week. Older players will have five off ice training sessions per week. At about age 12-14, weights are added to the off ice training program. Off ice training is very important in Russian hockey.
  • Coaches are evaluated at least once per year. Winning is not the major criteria in a coach’s evaluation. Player skill development and progress is the primary criteria for coaches. Ultimately coaches are evaluated by the number and quality of players they develop. Historically turnover is low.
  • The primary objective of each program is to develop players for the parent professional team. A secondary objective is to develop players for the national teams. Winning at the older ages (16 and older) is considered but is not a primary objective. A 17-year-old is eligible to play in the top professional league.
  • The practices we observed for the 5-8 year-olds worked on fundamental skills. Specific drills, requiring multiple skills, were run for long periods of time (15 to 30 minutes) and emphasized repetition. The overall pace was moderate. The coach gave verbal instruction and occasionally stopped practice for demonstration. We saw practices at this level where a player had a puck on his stick for the entire session. Puck possession and puck protection are high priorities in Russian hockey.
  • We observed a few practices for 17-22 year olds. Here one vs. one battles, odd man situations and puck movement seemed to be the focus. The pace of these practices was very high. There were three coaches on the ice and there were skill stations.
  • Tactics and systems are not introduced in Russian hockey until ages 14-16.

Summary of game to practice ratios for 2008:

This may vary slightly from club to club. The following is an attempt to summarize the four clubs we visited.

Birth year (age) – games per season – practice/training information per week

2003 (5) – No games – skate 3-4 times per week

2002 (6) – No games – skate 4-5 days; 1-2 off-ice sessions

2001 (7) – 10-15 games – practice 5 days; 2 to 3 off-ice sessions

2000 (8) – 15-20 games – practice 5 days; 3 off-ice sessions

1999 (9) – 20-30 games – practice 5 days; 3 off-ice sessions

1998 (10) – 30-35 games – practice 5 days; 3 off-ice sessions

1997 (11) – 42 games – practice 5 days; 3 office sessions

1996 (12) – 55 games – practice 5 days; 3 off-ice sessions

1995 (13) – 60 games – practice 5 days; 3 off-ice sessions

1994 (14) – 70 games – practice 5 days; 3 off-ice sessions

1993 (15) – 70 games – practice 5 days; 3 off-ice sessions

1992 (16) – 75 games – 2 practices per day 5 times per week; 5 off-ice sessions

1991 (17) – 75 games – 2 practices per day 5 times per week; 5 off-ice sessions

1990 (18) – 75 games – 2 practices per day 5 times per week; 5 off-ice sessions

Mark & I visited the University of Sport in St. Petersburg, enrollment of 10,000 students. Leonid Mikhno, Director Ice Hockey Department was our host. We gave a 90-minute presentation on the USA Hockey Coaching Education Program to a class of 35 students. There is a similar university in Moscow.

We met with about 25 coaches from CKA Hockey Club in St. Petersburg. Our host was Rafail Ishmatov, St. Petersburg Youth Hockey Director. We presented an outline of the USA Hockey Coaching Education Program. We answered many questions about our program as well as the USA Hockey structure and objectives.

Youth Hockey in Russia – 2008:

Youth Hockey in Russia is club driven. The clubs are owned and administered by professional teams of the Russian Professional Elite League and is broadly governed by the Russian Hockey Federation. The federation dispenses state money to the clubs, deals with insurance issues, makes general youth program recommendations, selects coaches for and operates the national teams. There are 23 clubs in Moscow; 10 are members of the professional elite league. In St. Petersburg there is only one.

Although there are similarities between Russian Hockey and USA Hockey, the differences are cultural and in the points of emphasis. The Russians have issues with parents as well as the concern for cost just like we do in USA Hockey. They want to grow their registration but availability of rinks and ice time are issues. Players having fun is not a priority in Russian hockey. The number of indoor rinks is 168. The weather changes have reduced outdoor ice facilities to almost none. Another issue in Moscow is the traffic and the ability of parents to get young players to the rink. Players tend to play for the club nearest their home. Hockey appears to part of the school physical education curriculum. They approach the game the same as one would approach taking courses in school.

We asked each club about girls’ hockey. There was not a girls program in any of the four clubs we visited. A few girls do skate with the younger ages. They are often put in older groups (up to two years older) if they pass the testing. Spartak has a girls training program. Talented girls usually migrate there. Currently there are 257 registered Russian girls playing hockey.

  • There is generally no cost for the ice.
  • Players are put in groups by birth year. Players with the same birth year skate and play together. A player can move to an older birth year if he passes evaluation and testing. A player cannot move up more than two years.
  • The clubs are open to any 5 & 6 year old that wants to play. The emphasis is skating. Players at this age will skate for one year without a stick. There are no games for 5 & 6 year olds. Usually the club has 60 to 80 skaters in this group. Dynamo had 200 in 2008. Parents pay for equipment.
  • Each club evaluates their players – this evaluation occurs in either May or August.
  • Seven-year-olds are evaluated and tested. They will play 10-15 games. These games are short ice but not “cross ice”.
  • Players eight and under use a lighter black puck. They will play 15-20 games. These games are “short ice” but not cross ice.
  • At the end of the season nine-year-olds are tested. Those that do not meet high standard are dismissed. Those not selected can try another (less competitive) club or they drop out. Here about 40% of the original group advance, roughly 35 out of the 60 kids.
  • At the end of season 10-year-olds are tested, about 40% (25) of the original 60 move on. From this point on drop out/dismissal is minimal.
  • Movement of players from one club to another does occur. Any player from another club will be evaluated and tested before he is accepted.
  • Although most of the players with a club start at age 5, 6 or 7, occasionally a club will get a first year player that is 8, 9 or 10. In this instance these players take skating for one year, are then tested and their future with the club is determined. Those 11 and older are selected and must meet high standards to continue.
  • Goalies receive specific specialized training as early as age eight. This can be two extra sessions per week.
  • The Russians teach and allow checking along the boards for 8-year-olds. There is currently discussion within Russia about this practice. The opinion of the clubs we visited is that it will continue.
  • Russians are just as concerned with recruiting players as we are. Russian athletes tend to move to soccer.
  • Russians do not play club hockey year round. There are summer camps but the clubs encourage their players to play other sports.
  • Youth players 12 and under wear neck guards.

People we met:


Barry Smith – Head Coach – CKA Hockey Director

Misha Manchik – Executive Assistant Coach

Rafail Ishmatov – St. Petersburg Youth Hockey Director

Yury Kulikov – Interpreter Assistant to Barry Smith


Pavel – Hockey Director


Vladimir Polupanov – Hockey Director

CSKA – Red Army:

Sergey Babinov – Hockey Director

YCKA University of Sport – St Petersburg:

Leniod Mikhno – President

Yuri Balashov – Honorable National Coach of Russia

Moscow Guide/Interpreter: Sasha Golovko


Here’s the link directly to this blog post..